Two Protein Pastries, Different Vibe
Magic Spoon now offers two protein pastry lines: the New! Protein Pastries in Strawberry and Cinnamon Brown Sugar, and the S'mores Protein Pastry in a 6-pack. Both are designed for a high-protein, keto-friendly lifestyle with 0g of sugar per serving, but they deliver different flavor experiences. Here's how they compare based on what the catalog confirms.
What the Catalog Tells Us
- New! Protein Pastries - Strawberry and Cinnamon Brown Sugar: New! Protein Pastries from Magic Spoon, available in Strawberry and Cinnamon Brown Sugar. High-protein formula, keto-friendly, 0g sugar per serving. This is the core option for someone who wants a straightforward, fruity or cinnamon-sweet pastry with zero sugar and high protein.

New! Protein Pastries - Strawberry and Cinnamon Brown Sugar - Pastries 6p - S'mores Pastries - Faire: S'mores Protein Pastry: soft-baked, frosted, with chocolatey filling and marshmallow flavor. Contains 11g protein, 6g fiber, and at least 80% less sugar than the leading toaster pastry. This option is for those who crave a nostalgic, dessert-like experience with higher fiber and a campfire-inspired flavor profile.

Pastries 6p - S'mores Pastries - Faire
Flavor Profile at a Glance
- New! Protein Pastries (Strawberry / Cinnamon Brown Sugar): Two distinct flavors: fruity strawberry or warm cinnamon brown sugar. No frosting or filling mentioned in the catalog. Designed for a clean, high-protein snack.
- S'mores Protein Pastry (6-pack): Soft-baked, frosted, with chocolatey filling and marshmallow flavor. Aimed at recreating the campfire s'mores experience with a richer, more indulgent taste.
Nutritional Differences Worth Noting
The S'mores Pastry specifically lists 11g protein and 6g fiber per serving. The New! Protein Pastries catalog mentions a high-protein formula but does not provide exact protein or fiber numbers in the supplied evidence. If fiber content is a priority for you, the S'mores option has a clear advantage. Both products are keto-friendly with 0g sugar.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose the New! Protein Pastries if you want a simpler, fruit or cinnamon flavor with zero sugar and a high-protein boost, and you don't need the extra fiber or frosting. Choose the S'mores Protein Pastry if you're after a dessert-like, frosted pastry with higher fiber and a nostalgic campfire taste. The catalog does not confirm detailed macros for the New! line, so if exact protein grams matter most, the S'mores pack gives you a clear number.


